"It’s not fair to say that any performance steals the show, but having also seen Tolpegin in last season’s “The Prom,” I will say she plays her roles with such flamboyance that it’s hard to tear your eyes away from her when she’s on stage. She depicts (Helen) Hubbard with wise-cracking ebullience and a liberal sprinkling of humor."
"Murder on the Orient Express" Pioneer Theatre 2023
Gephardt Daily, Daisy Blake

“Peggy White (Anne Tolpegin), the long-suffering foreman’s wife….Tolpegin’s voice caused the audience to sit up straight the first time she belted out a line and her solo, “Sail Away,” nearly brought the crowd to its feet.”
 "The Last Ship" Pioneer Theatre 2016
Salt Lake Magazine, Jeremy Pugh

"Madame DeFarge, that indefatigable knitter, however, brings us back. Played by understudy Anne Tolpegin (for Natalie Toro), DeFarge brings the French Revolution to a personal level. Her performance of "Out of Sight, Out of Mind" is a fire-breathing show-stopper"
 A Tale of Two Cities, Broadway 2008
New York Theatre Guide, Barbara Mehlman & Geri Manus